In France, the barrower’s action against the bank who advised him, in compensation for the loss of the chance to purchase a more adequate insurance cover becomes time barred after five years within the date of the insurer’s refusal to cover a loss.

French High Court, commercial chamber, 6 January 2021, case No.18-24.954

BNP Paribas grants a loan to an individual in return for two guarantees: the purchase of a borrower’s insurance and a banking, and a suretyship issued by Crédit Logement.

The borrower placed on sick leave asks the insurer to take over the repayments of his loan. The insurer opposes the fact that the borrower has reached the age beyond which his health risk is no longer contractually covered.

Because of the borrower’s default, BNP Paribas terminates the loans agreement and triggers Credit Logement’s suretyship for the payment of the loan’s remaining balance. Credit Logement then claims for repayment against the borrower who, in turn, claims for damages against BNP Paribas on the ground that they have wrongfully advised him to purchase an insurance cover unfitted to his situation.

Required to rule on the five-year time limit applicable to the claim against BNP Paribas, the court of appeal of Bastia decided that it started to run on the date on which the loan was granted to the borrower, as it was the date on which the borrower became informed of the terms and conditions of the litigious insurance cover.

On the ground of Articles 2224 of the French Civil Code and L. 110-4 of the French Commercial Code, the French High Court ruled that that the litigious five year time limit starts to run not on the date on which the insured becomes aware of the terms and conditions of his insurance cover but on the date on which he becomes aware or should become aware of the facts giving rise to his legal action on the ground of the wrongful advice provided to him when purchasing the said cover. In the present case, such date corresponded to the day on which the insurer refused to cover the borrower’s sickness on the ground of the age limit provided by the contract.

Business Law

Arst Avocats advises its clients in the following matters related to business law:

  • Advice on the regulations applicable to the client. Dealing with a wide range of issues relating to Contract Law (contract law or special contract law and contractual or tortious liability) and intervenes at the various stages (negotiation, conclusion, execution and termination) of the contractual relationship between the company and its partners or clients;
  • Intervention at all stages of disputes with which the company is confronted within the framework of its activity and represents it, if necessary, before the competent courts or within the framework of alternative dispute resolution procedures (mediation, arbitration, et seq.).
JEFFERSON LARUE

JEFFERSON LARUE

partner

Lawyer at the Paris Bar since 2000, holder of a Master’s Degree (D.E.S.S.) in Business Law (in partnership with HEC) from the Jean Monnet University (Paris XI).