Covid-19 & Contract Law – How to react in contractual relationships?

March 16, 2020 | Contracts

Situation 1: What can be invoked if one cannot deliver a good or perform a service?

Execution has become "impossible":                            Force majeure

Objectives : to avoid liability in the event of non-performance and/or to invoke the suspension or termination of the contract (where applicable with restitution).

Definition : contractual or legal, stipulating that it must be an event:

escaping the debtor's control;

which could not reasonably have been foreseen at the time the contract was concluded;

whose effects cannot be avoided by appropriate measures;

preventing the performance of the obligation.

Execution has become "impossible": Unforeseen circumstances

Purpose : to obtain a renegotiation (revision or adaptation of the contract) or the termination of the contract.

Definition : contractual or legal, stipulating three cumulative conditions:

the need for an unforeseen change in circumstances at the time the contract was concluded;

a change that makes the performance of the contract excessively onerous;

that the party affected by the change in circumstances has not agreed to assume the risk.

Points to be aware of
Force majeure :

Force majeure can be difficult to characterize (complex legal concept);

The contract may provide for the handling of force majeure;

Otherwise, the legal consequences (suspension or termination of the contract) depend on its effects.

Unforeseen circumstances:

The possibility of invoking unforeseen circumstances may depend on the date the contract was concluded (before or after October 1, 2016);

Unforeseen circumstances can be difficult to characterize (complex legal concept);

The contract may provide for the handling of unforeseen circumstances, or even exclude them;

Failing that, the handling of unforeseen circumstances may, in the absence of amicable renegotiation, require the intervention of a judge who will revise or terminate the contract.

Situation 2: What to do if we are waiting for the delivery of goods or the completion of a service that does not occur?

Forced execution (obtaining the intended execution)

Either by invoking the penalty clause of the contract if one is stipulated;

Either by seeking a court order, with a penalty payment, against the other party, to compel them to comply;

Either by having it done by a third party, at the expense of the other party.

Contract termination (being released from the contract, requiring a serious breach)

Either by invoking the termination clause of the contract if one is stipulated;

Either by simply notifying the debtor;

Either by requesting it in court (which takes longer).

Compensation for the consequences of non-performance (damages)

Either by invoking the penalty clause of the contract if one is stipulated;

Either by demanding them in court (which takes longer).

The suspension of its own obligations (exception of non-performance)

By refraining from executing during the period of non-execution by the other party.

The price revision

By requesting, after a formal notice, if and when the execution has taken place, a modification of the price proportional to the poor execution (delay, quantity or quality).

Points to be aware of
The choice between treatment methods

The methods of treatment that are compatible with each other can be combined (example: resolution + damages, forced execution + price revision);

The choice between processing methods depends on various criteria (expectations of the contracting party, prospects of execution by the other party, risks associated with the processing method, etc.);

The possibility of invoking certain mechanisms may depend on the date of conclusion of the contract (before or after October 1, 2016).

The conditions to be met

The implementation of certain mechanisms requires a serious breach;

Some mechanisms require prior formal notice (termination, price revision, implementation of liability);

Some mechanisms are implemented at the risk and peril of the co-contractor (unilateral termination, exception of non-performance).

The obstacles

The co-contractor may invoke, in particular, force majeure or unforeseen circumstances; the co-contractor may also be subject to collective proceedings which could paralyze the mechanisms in question.

Download

French

English Version –> Covid-19 & Contract law: How to react in contractual relations?

The Spanish version –> Covid-19 & Contract news: How to respond to contractual relationships?

Morgan Jamet

Morgan Jamet

Speak to a lawyer

Your situation deserves a tailored analysis

Describe your case in a few lines. A lawyer from the firm will get back to you within 48 hours.

4 offices to welcome you

  • Paris8 villa Poirier
  • Courbevoie,37 rue Adam Ledoux
  • Aix-en-Provence,235 rue Louis Broglie
  • Lesparre-Médoc19 avenue de Bordeaux
A contractual dispute? Let's talk about it.CallSchedule an appointment

Read next

On the same subject

All publications

Subscribe to our newsletter

Receive the latest news and updates from our team.

 

See you soon!