The health crisis linked to Covid-19 justifies the application of the doctrine of unforeseen circumstances in contracts (Article 1195 of the Civil Code)

April 7, 2021 | Contracts

The Paris Commercial Court considers in this case that the health crisis constitutes an unforeseeable change of circumstances "because it made the search for a business, as provided for by the protocol agreement, impossible due to the government-imposed closure of all bars and restaurants and that the consequences of this unforeseen event were excessively onerous for [the insured] causing him to lose the financial advantage provided by the possibility of lifting the suspensive condition".

Commercial Court of Paris, March 15, 2021, No. 2020048008

In this case, an insurance company signed a memorandum of understanding with its insured before the start of the Covid-19 pandemic, the purpose of which was to compensate the insured following a fire.

Among the conditions precedent conditioning the payment of the compensation is the conclusion of a new commercial lease before October 27, 2020.

Due to the health crisis, and despite numerous unsuccessful searches which the insured has provided evidence of, the insured is unable to conclude a new commercial lease before the agreed date.

Since the suspensive condition was not met, the insurer refuses to pay the compensation.

Seized of the matter, the Paris Commercial Court considered in this instance that the health crisis constituted an unforeseeable change in circumstances " because it rendered the search for a business, as stipulated in the protocol agreement, impossible due to the government-imposed closure of all bars and restaurants, and that the consequences of this unforeseen event were excessively onerous for [the insured], causing them to lose the financial advantage provided by the possibility of the suspensive condition being lifted ." The conditions of Article 1195 of the Civil Code were thus clearly met.

In accordance with the powers conferred on judges under this article, the court postpones the date of fulfillment of the suspensive condition to a date later than that provided for in the protocol, thus allowing the insured to benefit from the insurance compensation.

Speak to a lawyer

Your situation deserves a tailored analysis

Describe your case in a few lines. A lawyer from the firm will get back to you within 48 hours.

4 offices to welcome you

  • Paris8 villa Poirier
  • Courbevoie,37 rue Adam Ledoux
  • Aix-en-Provence,235 rue Louis Broglie
  • Lesparre-Médoc19 avenue de Bordeaux
A contractual dispute? Let's talk about it.CallSchedule an appointment

Read next

On the same subject

All publications

Subscribe to our newsletter

Receive the latest news and updates from our team.

 

See you soon!