Your client owes several invoices, is no longer responding to reminders, and you learn that they are emptying their accounts or trying to sell their business. Obtaining a judgment will take months. By then, there may be nothing left to seize.
Precautionary attachment addresses this risk. It allows a creditor to freeze funds or assets belonging to their debtor before any judgment, with the judge's authorization, if their claim appears well-founded and its recovery is threatened. This is the rule set forth in Article L511-1 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures.
Without an enforceable judgment, the creditor must then initiate substantive proceedings within one month of the seizure. Freezing funds is not the same as collecting them. A precautionary seizure is only valid if it is subsequently implemented, and it is in this subsequent implementation that errors are made that invalidate it.
What a precautionary seizure prevents
An unavailability, not a payment
A precautionary attachment renders an asset unavailable. The debtor can no longer freely dispose of it, but the creditor is not paid immediately. Payment will only be made after obtaining an enforceable judgment and then converting the attachment into a judgment.
In the case of a bank account or a debt, the seizure order renders the funds unavailable up to the amount authorized by the judge. It also automatically entails the deposit of these funds (Article L523-1 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures).
This deposit is the least known advantage of the measure. It produces the effects stipulated in Article 2350 of the Civil Code, namely a special allocation for the benefit of the seizing party. The creditor who seizes first thus gains a real advantage over the others.
Precautionary seizure or judicial security
Article L511-1 provides for two forms of precautionary measure. Precautionary seizure concerns movable property: sums of money, receivables, equipment, stocks, vehicles, shares or securities.
Judicial security applies to real estate, a business, shares, partnership interests, or securities (Article L531-1). It does not prevent the sale of the asset. It gives the creditor a preferential right to the asset, to be paid from its proceeds.
The choice between the two is made based on the evidence. A debtor who owns real estate but has little cash is suitable for a security interest. A debtor who receives large sums of money but depletes their accounts over time is suitable for a seizure of receivables. The two measures can be combined.
What distinguishes it from attachment of earnings
An attachment order requires an enforceable judgment and immediately transfers the funds to the creditor. A precautionary attachment order is issued before this judgment and merely freezes the funds. It becomes an attachment order through a conversion process, once the judgment is obtained (Article L523-2).
| Criteria | Precautionary seizure | Attachment order | Judicial security |
|---|---|---|---|
| Enforceable title required | No, in principle, the judge's authorization is sufficient | Yes | No, in principle, the judge's authorization is sufficient |
| Immediate effect | Assets or funds rendered unavailable | Amounts allocated to the creditor | Right of first refusal on the property, without blocking its sale |
| Assets in question | Accounts, receivables, tangible and intangible assets | Amounts owed by a third party to the debtor | Building, business assets, company shares, securities |
| Next steps | Enforceable title, then conversion | Payment by the garnishee | Enforceable title, then final formalities |
What are the conditions for obtaining a precautionary seizure?
A claim that appears to be well-founded in principle
The judge does not ask you to prove a definite, exact, and due debt. He verifies that the debt appears to be well-founded in principle. A contract, signed purchase orders, invoices, and correspondence acknowledging the service provided make the debt plausible.
This flexibility has its limits. On March 27, 2025, the Court of Cassation ruled that the judge must examine the disputed points regarding the statute of limitations for the debt in order to assess its apparent validity (Cass. 2nd Civ., March 27, 2025, No. 22-18.847). A debt that is questionable on this ground undermines the entire measure.
Our interpretation is straightforward. A serious and well-documented challenge from the debtor can invalidate the apparent debt. A principled resistance cannot. The application must therefore anticipate the debtor's argument and respond to it with supporting documentation.
Circumstances that threaten recovery
The judge expects facts, not mere concern. An unpaid invoice is not enough. You must demonstrate a concrete risk that payment will become impossible or significantly more difficult if you wait for the judgment.
Useful elements include, for example, the following:
- unpaid debts to several creditors, or recent registrations of liens;
- the sale of assets, business assets or operating equipment;
- a transfer of headquarters, accounts or activity to another structure;
- prolonged silence after a clear formal notice;
- published accounts that reveal losses or deteriorated equity.
A formal notice that goes unanswered strengthens the case, because it establishes the date of the refusal to pay. Our article on formal notices sent by lawyers details their drafting and effects.
Cases where the judge does not have to authorize the seizure
Prior authorization is not required when the creditor has an enforceable title or a court decision that is not yet enforceable (Article L511-2). The same applies to an unpaid check, accepted bill of exchange, or promissory note.
The text also addresses unpaid rent resulting from a written lease for a building, as well as certain condominium fees. A commercial landlord can therefore initiate a seizure directly through a bailiff. Our article on commercial rent recovery covers this case.
The exemption from authorization does not exempt from the substantive conditions. Even in these cases, the judge may lift the measure if it appears that the conditions of article L511-1 are not met (article L512-1).
The competent judge and the form of the application
Authorization is granted by the enforcement judge of the place where the debtor resides (Articles L511-3 and R511-2). Any clause to the contrary is deemed null and void, and the judge wrongly seized must raise the issue of lack of jurisdiction ex officio (Article R511-3).
For a commercial debt, and before any legal proceedings, the president of the commercial court may also grant it (article L511-3). In jurisdictions where the economic activities court is being piloted, the judge to be seized is verified before filing.
The application takes the form of a petition (Article R511-1). The debtor is not heard, thus preserving the element of surprise. On pain of invalidity, the order specifies the amount of the guaranteed sums and details the assets covered (Article R511-4).
Which of the debtor's assets should be targeted as a priority?
The choice of asset often determines the effectiveness of the seizure. A poorly chosen asset stalls the case without creating any real pressure on the debtor. A well-chosen asset forces them to return to the negotiating table.
Bank accounts
This is the most direct measure. The bailiff notifies the bank of the seizure, which then declares the available balance. Transactions pending at the time of the seizure can still modify this balance during a short adjustment period (Article L162-1).
If the debtor is an individual, for example a sole trader, the bank will leave them with a subsistence allowance equal to the flat-rate amount of the RSA (French minimum income benefit) for a single person (article R162-2). This rule does not apply to a company.
Receivables from its own customers
A debtor who invoices frequently but maintains little cash flow can have their assets seized from their clients. The sum they owe becomes unavailable to you. The third party holding the assets must specify what they owe the debtor, and this information is included in the seizure order (Article R523-4).
A third party who fails to provide this information risks having to pay the amounts in question themselves if the debtor is found liable (Article R523-5). This rule gives the creditor significant leverage with the debtor's clients.
Equipment, stocks and vehicles
Tangible movable property can be seized wherever it is located, including at the premises of a third party. In the latter case, a judge's authorization is still required even if the creditor holds a title. The property remains in the debtor's custody, who can no longer sell or move it.
Certain assets are exempt from seizure, notably the tools of the trade necessary for the personal exercise of a professional activity. This protection targets the debtor's personal business activities. It is particularly relevant in the case of a sole proprietor.
What cannot be seized as a precautionary measure
An employee's wages cannot be subject to a precautionary attachment order (Article L3252-7 of the French Labor Code). Nor does this measure allow for the seizure of the company director's personal assets for a debt solely owed by the company.
To reach the company director, they must themselves be indebted, for example, because they acted as guarantor. Article R511-7 also sets out a specific time limit for guarantors. Our article on guarantees details these commitments.
Accounts in another EU country
If the debtor has moved their funds to another Member State, Regulation (EU) No 655/2014 allows for the seizure of bank accounts under a European Bankruptcy Order. This order addresses cross-border disputes and applies in all EU countries except Denmark.
As in French law, the procedure is not adversarial: the debtor is informed only after the funds have been frozen. A member of the Aliant, Arst Avocats relies on this network when the debtor's assets are located outside of France.
A fund put up for sale
A supplier discovers that its client is looking to sell its business while several invoices remain unpaid. The sale price risks being received and then dispersed. The application must be filed before this payment is received, with the sale notice attached.
A disputed invoice at the last minute
At a service provider, the client suddenly claims non-conformity after months of silence. If the delivery reports are signed without reservation, the claim remains plausible. The judge will assess the seriousness of this belated dispute.
Funds sent abroad
A debtor company closes its French account and opens an account in another EU country. The European Precautionary and Attachment Order allows this account to be seized without waiting for a final judgment.
A recovery three weeks after the seizure
The creditor seized the assets and then filed a lawsuit within one month. The debtor was subsequently placed under judicial reorganization. Because the reorganization was not completed before this judgment, the seizure became invalid. The debtor still needs to file a claim within the prescribed time limit.
The seizure schedule, deadline by deadline
Almost every step is marked by lapse, meaning the measure disappears as if it had never existed. The following table lists these deadlines in the order in which they occur.
| Stage | Deadline | Text | Sanction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Execute the judge's authorization | 3 months from the date of the order | Article R511-6 | Expired authorization |
| Notify the debtor of the seizure of receivables | 8 days | Article R523-3 | Expired seizure |
| Initiate the procedure to obtain a title | 1 month after the seizure was carried out | Article R511-7 | Expired seizure |
| Notify the third party garnishee of the documents related to this procedure | 8 days from their date | Article R511-8 | Expired seizure |
| To contest the act of conversion, for the debtor | 15 days from the date of its notification | Article R523-9 | The objection is inadmissible |
3 months to execute the order
The judge's authorization lapses if the measure has not been executed within three months of the order (Article R511-6). In practice, this timeframe is rarely an issue. A successful seizure is carried out within days of the order, before the debtor is even aware of the procedure.
8 days to notify the debtor of the seizure
For a precautionary attachment of receivables, particularly on an account, the attachment must be notified to the debtor by a bailiff within 8 days, otherwise it becomes void (Article R523-3). The notification must include a copy of the order and the application, as well as the official report of the attachment.
It also clearly states the debtor's right to request the release of the attachment. An incomplete document is void. This formal verification is the responsibility of the bailiff, but the lawyer checks it before sending.
One month to initiate the substantive proceedings
If the seizure was carried out without an enforceable title, the creditor must, within one month of its execution, initiate proceedings or complete the formalities necessary to obtain a title. Otherwise, the measure becomes void (Article R511-7).
A request for a payment order, an application for interim relief, or a summons to appear in court is suitable. Our article onpayment orders details the procedure, and our page on debt collection between businesses helps you choose the right approach.
The text includes a safeguard. If a request for an order to pay filed within one month is rejected, the court can still be seized within one month of the rejection order. This safeguard only applies if the initial request was indeed filed within the time limit.
8 days to inform the third party involved in the seizure
When the measure is carried out by a third party, such as a bank, the creditor must provide them with a copy of the documents proving their efforts. They have eight days from the date of these documents to do so. Otherwise, the measure becomes invalid (Article R511-8).
This is the most frequently overlooked deadline, because it falls precisely when attention is focused on the substantive proceedings. The creditor has filed the summons on time, but the bank is unaware of it, and the seizure disappears.
Conversion, the final step before payment
Once the enforceable title is obtained, the creditor serves the third party with a notice of conversion, which constitutes a demand for payment (Article R523-7). This demand results in the immediate assignment of the seized debt, up to the amount the third party has acknowledged owing (Article L523-2).
A copy of the conversion order is served on the debtor, who has 15 days to contest it before the enforcement judge (Articles R523-8 and R523-9). If there is no contestation, the third party holding the funds pays upon presentation of a certificate of non-contestation.
Seize the opportunity first, or act on the substance of the matter first
When the debtor is solvent and the debt straightforward, a payment order alone is often sufficient. When the debtor shows signs of evasion, a precautionary attachment is the first step, because a judgment obtained against empty assets is useless.
In our debt recovery cases, we prepare the application for seizure and the summons that will initiate proceedings simultaneously, not one after the other. The one-month deadline doesn't allow enough time to build a solid case after the fact on a disputed matter.
Mistakes that invalidate a precautionary seizure
Let the one-month deadline pass
The month stipulated in Article R511-7 begins from the date of execution of the seizure, not from the date of the order or notification. A creditor who waits for the debtor's response before deciding on further action often loses their position without having been paid.
Forgetting a denunciation
Two actions are required to avoid lapse: notification to the debtor within 8 days of the seizure of receivables, and then service of the documents relating to the substantive proceedings on the third party holding the seized assets. The second action is the more precarious, because it requires monitoring the substantive proceedings day by day.
Asking for too much, or without a real threat
A request that inflates the amount or describes a vague threat risks having the seizure lifted. However, when the judge orders the seizure lifted, the creditor may be ordered to compensate for the harm caused by the measure (Article L512-2).
An operating account that is wrongfully frozen can prevent the debtor from paying their employees or suppliers. The resulting damages will then be real. The claim must remain proportionate to the debt and the demonstrated threat.
Believing that seizure is enough
Until it is converted into a judgment, a precautionary attachment is ineffective. If the debtor in financial difficulty enters insolvency proceedings before conversion, the attachment becomes void. The time between the attachment and the conversion is therefore the period of risk.
The three reflexes that protect the measure
- Compile the threat file before the request, with dated and verifiable documents.
- Prepare the document that will commit the funds at the same time as the application for seizure.
- Notify the conversion act as soon as the title is enforceable, without waiting for an amicable reminder.
If the debtor enters insolvency proceedings
An unconverted seizure no longer has any effect
The judgment initiating safeguard, reorganization, or liquidation proceedings stays or prohibits enforcement proceedings by prior creditors (Article L622-21 of the French Commercial Code). A precautionary attachment that has not been converted before this judgment can no longer be completed.
The Court of Cassation reiterated this principle in a judicial liquidation case. The suspension of enforcement proceedings then entails the release of any unconverted precautionary attachment (Cass. com., November 27, 2019, No. 18-19.861). The benefit derived from the deposit disappears with it.
Conversely, a seizure converted before the commencement of insolvency proceedings has had its effect of transferring ownership. The funds have left the debtor's assets and are now in the creditor's possession, and the insolvency proceedings do not reclaim them. There are often only a few days between these two situations.
Seizure carried out during the suspect period
Any protective measures taken since the date of cessation of payments are null and void, unless the seizure or registration predates that date (Article L632-1 of the French Commercial Code). The court sets this date and may postpone it for up to 18 months before the commencement of insolvency proceedings.
A seizure carried out when the debtor was already insolvent is therefore subject to invalidity. The creditor is not always aware of this at the time of the seizure. This is yet another reason to act at the first signs, rather than at the last minute.
The reflex that remains: to declare the claim
Once the proceedings have begun, the creditor no longer pursues the debtor: they file their claim with the court-appointed administrator or liquidator within two months of the judgment's publication in the BODACC (Official Bulletin of Civil and Commercial Announcements). Our article on filing claims details the process.
The line is clear. A precautionary seizure is no longer possible against a company already in insolvency proceedings for a debt incurred before the judgment. Our page on judicial reorganization explains the effects of this judgment.
Dispute, release and creditor's liability
The debtor may request the release at any time
If the conditions are not met, the judge may order the release at any time, after hearing or summoning the parties. It is the creditor's responsibility to prove that the required conditions are met (Article R512-1).
The application is brought before the judge who authorized the seizure. If the seizure was carried out without authorization, it goes before the enforcement judge of the debtor's place of residence. For a commercial debt, and before any legal proceedings, the president of the commercial court may also be seized (Article R512-2).
A guarantee can replace seizure
At the debtor's request, the judge may substitute any other measure suitable for safeguarding the interests of the parties for the seizure. The provision of an irrevocable bank guarantee, in accordance with the requested measure, results in the release of the seizure (Article L512-1).
For a debtor acting in good faith whose operating account is frozen, this is often the quickest way out. For the creditor, a bank guarantee is sometimes better than a frozen account, because it is no longer dependent on the debtor's cash flow.
Who pays the seizure costs?
The costs incurred by a protective measure are borne by the debtor, unless the judge decides otherwise (Article L512-2). This principle does not cover lawyers' fees, which are subject to a separate claim before the trial judge.
The risk of damages and interest
When the seizure order has been issued, the creditor may be ordered to compensate for the harm caused by the measure (Article L512-2). This risk does not preclude action. It requires seizing assets of a defensible amount, selected from carefully chosen assets, and with a solid case demonstrating the threat.
A useful effect even in case of failure
A protective measure interrupts the statute of limitations (Article 2244 of the Civil Code). The lifting of the seizure does not have retroactive effect: the lifted measure retains its interruptive effect (Cass. 2nd Civ., May 17, 2023, No. 21-11.987). Therefore, a lifted seizure has, at the very least, reset the statute of limitations.
Block quickly, but with the sequel already prepared
Which makes for a useful seizure
Precautionary attachment is one of the few tools that reverses the balance of power before any judgment. It deprives the debtor of access to their funds and often forces them to negotiate. But it doesn't pay anyone until it is converted into a judgment.
Its value therefore depends on three decisions made even before the application: the property to be targeted, the amount to be claimed, and the procedure that will grant the title within a month. Made at the right time, these decisions transform a temporary freeze into payment.
The three questions to ask yourself before seizing
Will my claim withstand the dispute the debtor will raise? Do I have dated evidence that demonstrates a risk to recovery? What substantive legal action can I initiate within the month, and who will follow up on the daily notices?
At the firm, these cases are handled in particular by Thomas Vidal, a commercial litigation lawyer, within the business and corporate litigation. When the debtor is in financial difficulty, the cases are managed by the insolvency and restructuring.
Frequently asked questions about precautionary seizure
Can a precautionary seizure be carried out without a court order?
Yes. A creditor without a legal title requests authorization from the enforcement judge by application, without the debtor being heard. They must demonstrate a claim that appears to be well-founded and a risk to its recovery (Article L511-1 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures). They then have one month after the seizure to initiate the procedure that will grant them an enforceable title.
How long do the funds remain blocked?
The funds remain unavailable until the seizure is lifted by the judge, lapses, or is converted into an attachment order. In practice, their freezing therefore lasts for the duration of the substantive proceedings. This is why compliance with the deadlines for notification and service on the third party garnishee is as important as the initial authorization.
Can the debtor have the precautionary seizure lifted?
Yes, at any time, before the judge who authorized it. It is then up to the creditor to prove that the conditions are met (Article R512-1). The debtor can also offer an irrevocable bank guarantee that complies with the measure, which results in the release of the attachment (Article L512-1). Finally, the judge can replace the attachment with another measure that protects both parties.
Who pays the costs of a precautionary seizure?
In principle, the debtor is liable, unless the judge decides otherwise (Article L512-2 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures). The same article stipulates that, if the seizure is lifted, the creditor may be ordered to compensate for the harm caused by the measure. A disproportionate or poorly justified seizure can therefore cost the creditor more than it gains.
What happens to the seizure if my debtor is liquidated?
If the attachment order was not converted into an attachment order before the commencement of proceedings, it ceases to have effect and its release follows the cessation of proceedings (French Supreme Court, Commercial Chamber, November 27, 2019, No. 18-19.861). The debt must then be declared within two months of the publication of the judgment in the BODACC (Official Bulletin of Civil and Commercial Announcements). However, an attachment order converted before this judgment remains valid.
Does a precautionary seizure interrupt the statute of limitations?
Yes. Article 2244 of the Civil Code provides that a protective measure taken pursuant to the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures interrupts the statute of limitations. The Court of Cassation has clarified that the lifting of the measure does not have retroactive effect, so the lifted measure retains this effect (Cass. 2nd Civ., May 17, 2023, No. 21-11.987).
